Oakwyn Realty Ltd.
BuyNew ListingsAdvanced SearchMapValuationMarket Reports
Sign InGet Alerts
  1. Home
  2. Ontario
  3. Tay (Port Mcnicoll)
  • Ottawa
  • Kitchener
  • Windsor
  • Toronto (Waterfront Communities)
  • Brantford
  • Waterloo
  • Toronto (Church-Yonge Corridor)
  • Mississauga (City Centre)
  • Toronto (Willowdale East)
  • Toronto (Bay Street Corridor)
  • Toronto (Islington-City Centre West)
  • Toronto (Mimico)
  • Midland
  • Woodland Beach
  • The Blue Mountains

Ontario

Tay (Port Mcnicoll) Real Estate

28 homes for sale • Median $537,250

28Active Listings
$537,250Median Price
30Avg Days on Market
16Detached9Land2Condo1Multi- Unit

Homes for Sale in Tay (Port Mcnicoll)

28 properties available

View all
510 Mary Street

$569,500

510 Mary Street

Tay (Port McNicoll), Ontario

3bed2bath
323 BELL Street

$449,000

323 BELL Street

Tay (Port McNicoll), Ontario

2bed1bath
264 Kingfisher Avenue

$524,900

264 Kingfisher Avenue

Tay (Port McNicoll), Ontario

3bed1bath
426 Seventh Avenue

$124,900

426 Seventh Avenue

Tay (Port McNicoll), Ontario

55 Dock Lane 28

$415,000

55 Dock Lane 28

Tay (Port McNicoll), Ontario

450 Assiniboia Street

$450,000

450 Assiniboia Street

Tay (Port McNicoll), Ontario

2bed2bath
550 Second Avenue

$699,900

550 Second Avenue

Tay (Port McNicoll), Ontario

2bed2bath
163 Patterson Boulevard

$599,900

163 Patterson Boulevard

Tay (Port McNicoll), Ontario

4bed4bath
19 Dock Lane

$599,000

19 Dock Lane

Tay (Port McNicoll), Ontario

1bed1bath
21 Dock Lane

$599,000

21 Dock Lane

Tay (Port McNicoll), Ontario

1bed1bath
366 TALBOT Street

$205,900

366 TALBOT Street

Tay (Port McNicoll), Ontario

3bed1bath
503 Margaret Street

$129,900

503 Margaret Street

Tay (Port McNicoll), Ontario

Advanced Search in Tay (Port Mcnicoll)

Showing 12 of 28 listings

About Tay (Port Mcnicoll) Real Estate

Tay (Port McNicoll) is a charming community nestled along the shores of Georgian Bay, offering a unique blend of natural beauty and small-town charm. Originally established as a lumber town in the late 19th century, Port McNicoll has evolved into a picturesque waterfront locale that attracts both year-round residents and seasonal visitors. The town features a rich maritime history, with remnants of its shipbuilding past still evident in the local architecture and community spirit. Notably, the historic Port McNicoll railway station stands as a testament to its vibrant past, inviting exploration and appreciation from newcomers and residents alike.

What sets Tay apart is its stunning natural landscape, which includes numerous parks and access to pristine beaches like the nearby Awenda Provincial Park. This lush area is perfect for outdoor enthusiasts, offering trails for hiking, biking, and proximity to water activities such as boating and fishing. The friendly atmosphere and a strong sense of community make Tay an ideal place for families, retirees, and anyone seeking a peaceful lifestyle away from the hustle and bustle of larger cities.

The area is also characterized by its unique blend of local shops, cafes, and services, fostering a tight-knit community feel. While the charm of the town is evident in its quaint streets, modern conveniences are just a short drive away in larger centers such as Midland and Orillia, providing residents with a perfect balance of tranquility and accessibility. Tay (Port McNicoll) is a destination that not only preserves its historical roots but also embraces a vibrant future, making it a sought-after location for diverse buyer types.

29 active listings with a median price of $524,450.

Lifestyle & Community

Living in Tay (Port McNicoll) offers a serene lifestyle surrounded by nature and a close-knit community vibe. Residents enjoy a relaxed pace of life, with ample opportunities for outdoor activities, including hiking, fishing, and enjoying the waterfront. Community events such as the annual Port McNicoll Regatta and seasonal festivals foster a strong sense of belonging and togetherness. The local culture is enriched by the welcoming spirit of its residents, making it an ideal home for families and retirees alike, all while maintaining easy access to urban amenities.

Local Amenities

  • Public library
  • Local grocery stores
  • Community parks
  • Waterfront access
  • Dining options including cafes and restaurants
  • Sports facilities
  • Healthcare services
  • Public transit accessibility
  • Schools and educational institutions
  • Recreational centers
  • Marina services for boaters
  • Nearby golf courses

Points of Interest

  • Awenda Provincial Park
  • Historic Port McNicoll Railway Station
  • Georgian Bay
  • Tay Shore Trail
  • Local marina
  • The Port McNicoll Community Centre
  • Nearby Midland Cultural Centre
  • The Wye Marsh Wildlife Centre
  • Little Lake Park
  • Huronia Museum and Heritage Centre

Market Overview

The real estate market in Tay (Port McNicoll) is currently active, with 29 listings and a median listing price of $524,450. Homes are selling relatively quickly, averaging just 30 days on the market. This indicates a competitive market where buyers are encouraged to act swiftly. The appealing prices for homes compared to nearby markets make this area attractive for first-time buyers and families looking for more space without a hefty price tag.

Investment Outlook

Tay (Port McNicoll) presents a strong investment opportunity, especially as the demand for waterfront properties continues to rise. The area’s rental market is also promising, with a growing number of seasonal rentals catering to tourists. Development trends show interest in enhancing local infrastructure and amenities, which can increase property values over time, making it a strategic choice for long-term investment.

Ideal For

Tay (Port McNicoll) is ideal for first-time buyers seeking affordable housing options, families looking for a safe and community-oriented environment, and retirees desiring a peaceful lifestyle by the water. Additionally, investors may find attractive opportunities in the rental market, making it a versatile choice for various buyer types.

Browse by Property Type

Condos(2)Detached Homes(16)Land(9)Condos Under $500KCondos Under $750KCondos Under $1M
View Tay (Port Mcnicoll) Market Report →

Nearby Cities

MidlandWoodland BeachThe Blue Mountains

Frequently Asked Questions About Tay (Port Mcnicoll)

There are currently 28 active residential listings in Tay (Port Mcnicoll). This includes detached homes, condos, townhouses, and other property types. Listings are updated throughout the day from CREA's DDF®.

Search Listings Online

County, city, postal, or street. Real-time updates and expert insights.

Search

  • All Listings
  • New Listings
  • Saved Searches

Popular Areas

  • Toronto
  • Vancouver
  • Montreal
  • Calgary
  • Edmonton

Support

  • Contact Us
  • Privacy Policy
  • Terms of Use
  • support@searchlistingsonline.ca
Oakwyn Realty Ltd.

Oakwyn Realty Ltd.

Search Listings Online Inc.

3195 Oak St, Vancouver, BC V6H 2L2

REALTOR®, REALTORS®, and the REALTOR® logo are certification marks that are owned by REALTOR® Canada Inc. and licensed exclusively to The Canadian Real Estate Association (CREA). These certification marks identify real estate professionals who are members of CREA and who must abide by CREA's By-Laws, Rules, and the REALTOR® Code. The MLS® trademark and the MLS® logo are owned by CREA and identify the quality of services provided by real estate professionals who are members of CREA. The information contained on this site is based in whole or in part on information that is provided by members of CREA, who are responsible for its accuracy. CREA reproduces and distributes this information as a service for its members and assumes no responsibility for its accuracy.

The listing content on this website is protected by copyright and other laws. Screen scraping, database scraping, and all other forms of automated data collection are prohibited.

© 2026 Search Listings Online. Powered by CREA DDF